The following posts provide a snapshot of the principal U.S., European and global financial regulatory developments of interest to banks, investment firms, broker-dealers, market infrastructures, asset managers and corporates.
Commodity Futures Trading Commission Finalizes Amendments to Rules Governing Chief Compliance Officer Duties and Annual Reporting Requirements for Certain Registrants
The Commodity Futures Trading Commission has unanimously approved final amendments to clarify and simplify its regulations governing the duties and annual reporting requirements for chief compliance officers at futures commission merchants, swap dealers and major swap participants. The amendments, first proposed in May 2017, are designed to clarify certain requirements (including as to the annual CCO report) as well as harmonize the CFTC's requirements with similar Securities and Exchange Commission rules that will be applicable to security-based swap dealers.
UK Regulators Finalize Rule Changes For Extending Individual Accountability Regime to Insurers
The U.K. Financial Conduct Authority and Prudential Regulation Authority have published Policy Statements confirming the near-final and final rule changes they will apply to extend the application of the Senior Managers & Certification Regimes to insurers. The Policy Statements do not make an changes to the prudential rules implementing Solvency II or to the wider U.K. regulatory framework for insurers.
The extended SM&CR will apply from December 10, 2018, subject to commencement regulations being made by HM Treasury. The SM&CR will apply to all insurers and reinsurers regulated by the FCA and the PRA. The Policy Statements will be of specific interest to Solvency II firms (that is, all firms within the scope of the U.K. rules implementing the Solvency II Directive), insurance special purpose vehicles (undertakings with permission to carry on the regulated activity of insurance risk transformation), insurers outside the scope of the Solvency II Directive (so-called Non-Directive Firms) and small run-off firms (all insurers with less than £25 million technical provisions that no longer have permission to write or acquire new business).
UK Conduct Regulator Issues Near-Final Rules on Extension of Individual Accountability Regime to All Financial Services Firms
The U.K. Financial Authority has published Policy Statements confirming the rule changes it will apply to extend the application of the Senior Managers & Certification Regimes to all FCA solo-regulated firms (that is, firms for which the FCA is both conduct and prudential regulator). At this stage, the rules are near-final as they are subject to commencement regulations that will be made by HM Treasury and they may also be amended by subsequent changes related to, for example, Brexit or SM&CR optimizations. The FCA also plans to consult separately on rules for benchmark-related activities.
The extended SM&CR will apply to all firms authorized under the Financial Services and Markets Act 2000 and regulated by the FCA, as well as EEA and third country (non-EEA) branches. SM&CR will be extended to FCA solo-regulated firms from December 9, 2019.
While insurance intermediaries, which are solo-regulated by the FCA, will fall within the FCA's new rules, the FCA and the Prudential Regulation Authority have separately published policy statements on the extension of the SM&CR to insurers.
European Banking Authority Proposes Updated Guidelines on Outsourcing by Financial Institutions
The European Banking Authority has launched a consultation on draft Guidelines on outsourcing arrangements. The proposed Guidelines are intended to update and replace the outsourcing guidelines issued in 2006 (by the EBA's predecessor, the Committee of European Banking Supervisors) that applied to outsourcing by credit institutions. The proposed Guidelines will have a wider scope, applying to all financial institutions that are within the scope of the EBA's mandate, namely credit institutions and investment firms subject to the Capital Requirements Directive, payment institutions and electronic money institutions. The proposed Guidelines also integrate the recommendation on outsourcing to cloud service providers that was published by the EBA in December 2017.
The proposed Guidelines set out a definition of outsourcing in line with delegated legislation under the revised Markets in Financial Instruments Directive. They cover: (i) proportionality and group application; (ii) the nature of outsourcing arrangements; (iii) the applicable governance framework; (iv) the outsourcing process; and (v) guidelines on outsourcing addressed to competent authorities. A separate Annex provides an illustrative template that could be used for complying with the requirement in the proposed Guidelines to maintain a register of all outsourcing arrangements at institution and group level where applicable.
European Central Bank Updates Guide to Management Body Fit and Proper Assessments
The European Central Bank has published an updated Guide to Fit and Proper assessments for the suitability of members of the management body and key function holders in significant institutions. The ECB is responsible for direct prudential supervision of certain significant banks based in the Eurozone as part of the Single Supervisory Mechanism. The ECB Guide covers fit and proper assessments of members of management bodies, both in their management function (executives) and supervisory function (non-executives). It applies to all institutions under the direct supervision of the ECB, namely in-scope credit institutions, financial holding companies and mixed financial holding companies. In the context of licensing or qualifying holdings, the ECB Guide will also apply to less significant institutions.
The ECB Guide has been updated following the publication of the joint European Banking Authority and European Securities and Markets Authority Guidelines on the suitability of management body members and key function holders, which will apply from June 30, 2018, and the EBA Guidelines on Internal Governance.
Financial Stability Board Publishes Toolkit to Abate Misconduct Risk
The Financial Stability Board has published a report, "Strengthening Governance Frameworks to Mitigate Misconduct Risk: A Toolkit for Firms and Supervisors." The report is part of the FSB's work on measures to reduce misconduct in the financial sector and follows the FSB's stocktake of endeavors by international bodies, national authorities, industry associations and firms.
The Toolkit is designed to provide firms and authorities with a set of tools that can be used, taking into account the applicable legislative, judicial and regulatory frameworks. Rather than creating an international standard or adopting a prescriptive approach, the FSB's Toolkit allows firms and supervisors to decide whether and how to use the Toolkit to address misconduct risk. The FSB also states that firms and their supervisors can use individual tools separately or in combination.
The Toolkit comprises 19 tools, divided into three categories and assigned between firms and national authorities.
UK Prudential Regulation Authority Publishes its 2018/19 Business Plan
The Prudential Regulation Authority has published its Business Plan for 2018/19 which sets out its strategic goals and workplan to deliver those goals. The PRA also published a consultation paper on its fees and levies for 2018/19 alongside the Business Plan as well as a report to the Prudential Regulation Committee on the adequacy of PRA resources and independence of PRA functions.
Read a summary of the PRA's goals and workplan.
UK Financial Conduct Authority Finalizes Rules Enhancing Governance of Authorized Fund Managers
The Financial Conduct Authority has published a Policy Statement and final rules relating to strengthening the governance arrangements of U.K. authorized fund managers. The need to enhance these arrangements was identified by the FCA in the Asset Management Market Study launched in 2015. The final AMMS report was published in June 2017 and set out remedies the FCA intended to implement to address identified issues. At the same time, the FCA published a consultation paper on the first set of proposals.
The Policy Statement sets out the FCA's response to the feedback on its proposals and the final rules and guidance. The new rules and guidance applies to U.K. AFMs in relation to their management of authorized funds (that is, authorized open-ended collective investment schemes). The rules will apply either on April 1, 2019 or on September 30, 2019, depending on the lead time that the FCA considers the industry needs to implement the required changes.
Read more for a summary of the FCA's decision on the various consultation points.
UK Financial Conduct Authority Consults on Proposals to Improve Disclosure to Fund Investors by Authorized Fund Managers
The Financial Conduct Authority has published a second consultation paper on remedies arising out of the Asset Management Market Study. This consultation concerns improving disclosure by authorized fund managers to their investors and should be read with the Policy Statement, final rules and revised guidance on enhanced governance arrangements for U.K. AFMs, which were published alongside the consultation paper. The FCA is proposing:
- new guidance on how AFMs should make fund objectives and investment policies clear and more useful for investors;
- new rules requiring managers to be clear about why (or why not) a benchmark has been used and how investors should assess the performance of the fund;
- new rules requiring AFMs that use benchmarks to use and reference them consistently across marketing materials;
- new rules requiring that where managers present past performance they must do so in an appropriate and consistent manner; and
- amending the performance fee rules to require that performance fees be calculated on performance net of other fees.
View the second consultation on remedies arising from the AMMS.
View details of the Policy Statement and final rules.
View the AMMS final report and the first consultation paper.
European Central Bank Issues Final Guides on Licensing Credit Institutions and FinTech Credit Institutions
The European Central Bank has published finalized versions of its guides “Guide to Assessments of Licence Applications” and “Guide to Assessments of FinTech Credit Institution Licence Applications”, following consideration of the responses to consultations on draft versions of the guides, which the ECB ran between September and November 2017.
The ECB has been exclusively competent, since November 2013, to authorize all Eurozone credit institutions and credit institutions established in any other EU Member States that participate in the Single Supervisory Mechanism via close cooperation arrangements.
The ECB exercises its competence in close cooperation with the relevant national regulators. The ECB has developed the Guides, which are not legally binding, to promote awareness and enhance the transparency of the assessment criteria and processes for establishing a credit institution within the SSM. These should serve as practical tools to support applicants and all other entities involved in the process of bank authorization to ensure a smooth and effective procedure and assessment.
European Banking Authority Final Guidelines on Internal Governance Under the Capital Requirements Directive
The European Banking Authority has published a compliance notification form on its website, seeking confirmation, by May 21, 2018, of compliance (or intention to comply) with the Final Guidelines on Internal Governance it published in September 2017.
The EBA was mandated under the Capital Requirements Directive to provide guidelines on the corporate governance arrangements, processes and mechanisms required under that Directive. CRD IV requires that institutions must have robust governance arrangements, which include a clear organizational structure with well-defined, transparent and consistent lines of responsibility, effective processes to identify, manage, monitor and report the risks they are or might be exposed to, adequate internal control mechanisms, including sound administration and accounting procedures and remuneration policies and practices that are consistent with and promote sound and effective risk management. The EBA consulted in October 2016 on proposed updates to its previous guidelines on internal governance, which were published in September 2011.
European Securities and Markets Authority and European Banking Authority Final Guidelines on Suitability of Management Body Members and Key Function Holders
Following consultation in late 2017, the European Securities and Markets Authority and European Banking Authority have jointly published final Guidelines on the assessment of the suitability of members of management bodies and key function holders in credit institutions, investment firms, financial holding companies and mixed financial holding companies. These assessments are required under the Capital Requirements Directive and the revised Markets in Financial Instruments Directive.
Under the CRD and MiFID II, an assessment of the suitability of members of a management body should take into account factors such as sufficiency of time commitment, honesty, integrity and independence of mind of a member of the management body. The management body must have adequate collective knowledge, skills and experience among its members. Firms should devote adequate human and financial resources to the induction and training of such members. Diversity is also to be taken into account when selecting members of the management body. In the case of key function holders, the Guidelines also specify requirements regarding the suitability of the heads of internal control functions and the chief financial officer of credit institutions and certain investment firms. The Guidelines apply to any other persons assessed as key function holders under the firm's risk-based approach. An Annex is provided as a template for firms to record the results of relevant assessments.
UK Banking Standards Board Publishes Principles for Strengthening Professionalism
The Banking Standards Board has published the "BSB Statement of Principles for Strengthening Professionalism - The role of the firm", which is a guiding statement of principles intended to assist banks and building societies to strengthen professionalism in the banking sector. The BSB has defined professionalism in UK banking as "attitudes, judgement and high standards of behaviour, knowledge and skill expected of individuals working in banking". The Statement consists of six principles, each of which is supported by action points on how the principle can be achieved.
The Statement does not impose any legal or regulatory obligations on firms or replace any regulation. It is intended to assist firms in structuring their own practices and to build on regulatory initiatives, such as the Senior Managers and Certification Regimes.
View the BSB Statement.
UK Regulator to Consult on Expanded Financial Services Register under the Senior Managers & Certification Regimes
The Financial Conduct Authority has announced that it will be putting forward proposals for aligning the Financial Services Register with the expanded Senior Managers & Certification Regimes. The SM&CR has been in place for banks, building societies, credit unions and PRA-designated investment firms since March 2016, whilst certain insurers have been subject to the separate Senior Insurance Managers Regime. The remainder of authorized firms have continued to be subject to the Approved Persons Regime. The FCA recently consulted on expanding the existing SM&CR to all other authorized firms.
Under the SM&CR, the FCA only approves Senior Managers and it is only these individuals that appear in the FS Register. The Certification Regime requires firms to certify that all individuals in roles which pose a risk of significant harm are "fit and proper".
Feedback on the proposals to extend the SM&CR indicated that there would be public value in including details of certification of employees and other important individuals at firms in the FS Register. The FCA intends to consult in the Summer on implementing that feedback. If these proposals are implemented, non-executive directors, financial advisers, traders and portfolio managers would appear in the revised FS Register.
View the FCA's statement.
View the proposals to extend the SM&CR.
UK Banking Standards Board Publishes Further Guidance on the Certification Regime
The U.K. Banking Standards Board has published further Supporting Guidance to its Statement of Good Practice on the Certification Regime: Fitness and Propriety Assessment Principles (known as Statement of Good Practice 1). The new Supporting Guidance, "Establishing Pass/Fail Criteria and Evidencing the F&P Assessment" (known as Supporting Guidance 2), aims to assist firms and other persons assessing fitness and propriety in making certification decisions, particularly in borderline cases. The Certification Regime is part of the regulatory reforms introduced in the U.K. to strengthen individual accountability (namely, the Senior Managers Regime, the Certification Regime and the Conduct Rules). It requires firms to certify that all individuals in roles which pose a risk of significant harm are "fit and proper." The U.K. regulators are proposing to extend the Certification Regime to all other regulated firms. The BSB was launched in April 2015 as an industry initiative to help raise standards of behavior and competence in the banking sector.
Federal Reserve Board Proposes Guidance Clarifying Risk Management Supervisory Expectations for Large Financial Institutions
The US Board of Governors of the Federal Reserve System issued proposed guidance for comment that would clarify supervisory expectations related to risk management for large financial institutions. This proposed guidance would complement the Federal Reserve Board's proposed rating system for large financial institutions and proposed guidance regarding supervisory expectations for bank boards of directors that were released in August of 2017. The proposed guidance provides core principles applicable to senior management, management of business lines, and independent risk management and controls. Under the proposed guidance, senior management is tasked with the management of the day-to-day operations of the institution, ensuring its safety and soundness and overseeing compliance with laws, regulations and internal policies and procedures.
Financial Conduct Authority Consults on Extending Senior Managers & Certification Regime to All FCA Regulated Firms and Both UK Regulators Consult on its Extension to Insurers
The Financial Conduct Authority has published a consultation paper on its proposed rule changes to implement the extension of the Senior Managers& Certification Regime (SM&CR) to all firms that are authorized under the Financial Services and Markets Act 2000 and solo-regulated by the FCA. The SM&CR has been in place for banks, building societies, credit unions and PRA-designated investment firms since March 2016, whilst certain insurers have been subject to the separate Senior Insurance Managers Regime. The remainder of authorized firms have continued to be subject to the Approved Persons Regime, which will be replaced when the extended application of SM&CR takes effect.
Given that the extension of SM&CR will capture a very wide range of firms, the FCA has tailored the principles and tools used for the banking regime to fit the different risks, impact and complexity of the firms that will be affected by the extended SM&CR. The rules proposed by the FCA comprise (i) a "core regime" consisting of a standard set of requirements that will apply to all FCA solo-regulated firms; (ii) an "enhanced regime" which will apply extra requirements to the very small number of solo-regulated firms whose size, complexity and potential impact on consumers warrant more attention; and (iii) a reduced set of requirements which will apply to firms the FCA has categorized as "limited scope" firms.
G20 Leaders Outline Action Plan Following Hamburg Summit
The G20 Leaders met in Hamburg, Germany on July 7-8, 2017 and have published a Leaders' Declaration and an Action Plan setting out the G20's strategy for achieving strong, sustainable, balanced and inclusive growth. The Action Plan includes ongoing and planned work on financial sector regulation and development.
UK Financial Conduct Authority Publishes Final Asset Management Market Study Report
The Financial Conduct Authority has published the final report of the Asset Management Market Study it launched in November 2015. The object of the AMMS was to investigate three core areas: (i) how asset managers compete to deliver value; (ii) whether asset managers are willing and able to control costs and quality along the value chain; and (iii) how investment consultants affect competition for institutional asset management. Furthermore, the FCA wanted to look at whether there are any barriers to innovation that prevent investors from obtaining better results. The FCA published an interim AMMS report in November 2016 which set out the FCA's provisional assessment of the way competition works for asset management services, the consequences for investors and the FCA's proposed remedies to tackle the issues.
The final AMMS report confirms the FCA's interim findings and proposes a package of remedies. The FCA has divided the remedies into three buckets: (i) remedies on which it has published a consultation alongside the final report; (ii) final remedies; and (iii) remedies on which it intends to consult later.
Prudential Regulation Authority Publishes Policy Statement on Strengthening Individual Accountability in Banking
The Prudential Regulation Authority has published a Policy Statement on strengthening individual accountability in banking. The Policy Statement provides the PRA's final policy on a number of issues. Among other things, the PRA has made modifications to the final rules, such as simplifying the draft definition of the new Chief Operations Senior Management Function and narrowing the new Prescribed Responsibility accompanying the Chief Operations SMF to focus on responsibility for the firm's performance of its obligations relating to outsourcing.
Financial Conduct Authority Publishes Policy Statement on Application of its Conduct Rules to Non-Executive Directors
The Financial Conduct Authority has published a Policy Statement on applying conduct rules in the Code of Conduct sourcebook to non-executive directors in the banking and insurance sectors. In-scope NEDs are those who do not hold Senior Management Functions and therefore are not subject to regulatory pre-approval under the Senior Managers & Certification Regime, the Prudential Regulation Authority's Senior Insurance Managers Regime, or the FCA's revised Approved Persons Regime.
The Policy Statement follows a Consultation in September 2016, which proposed that NEDs would be subject to the five FCA Individual Conduct rules on acting with integrity, acting with due skill, care and diligence, cooperating with the FCA and other regulators, having regard for customer interests and observing proper standards of market conduct. In addition, NEDs would be subject to the Senior Conduct rule requiring individuals to disclose any information of which the FCA or PRA would reasonably expect notice. The remaining Senior Conduct rules will not apply to a NED unless they are also a senior conduct rules staff member. The new rules will come into force on July 3, 2017.
View the Policy Statement.
Financial Conduct Authority Publishes Policy Statement on Remuneration in Capital Requirements Directive IV Firms
The Financial Conduct Authority has published a Policy Statement containing final Handbook text and guidance on the requirements for remuneration policies that apply to firms subject to the Capital Requirements Directive IV. Such firms are required to comply with the FCA's Remuneration Code. The FCA consulted on these from September to November 2016. The final rules are broadly as consulted upon, with minor changes to clarify the status of "retention awards" as being different from "guaranteed variable remuneration".
The FCA has aligned its Handbook provisions to comply with the European Banking Authority Guidelines on Sound Remuneration Policies, which came into force on January 1, 2017. The FCA has also published new non-Handbook guidance to address frequently asked questions on remuneration. The Prudential Regulation Authority further published a Policy Statement and final consolidated Supervisory Statement on its expectations on remuneration on April 12, 2017, which aims to bring its approach in line with the EBA Guidelines.
View the Policy Statement.
View the FCA Guidance.
View the EBA Guidance.
Financial Conduct Authority Publishes Policy Statement on Whistleblowing in UK Branches of Foreign Banks
The Financial Conduct Authority has published a Policy Statement introducing final rules on whistleblowing requirements for UK branches of overseas (EEA and third country) banks. The Policy Statement follows a consultation in September 2016 on a proposed approach for extending aspects of the Prudential Regulation Authority and FCA regime to require banks and insurers to introduce whistleblowing procedures internally. The proposals are broadly being implemented as consulted upon, with one minor change being the introduction of guidance reminding branches they may continue to have concurrent reporting obligations to their home state regulators. The rules will come into force on September 7, 2017.
View the Policy Statement.
Financial Conduct Authority Publishes Policy Statement and Final Guidance on the Duty of Responsibility
The Financial Conduct Authority has published a Policy Statement and final Guidance on how it will enforce the "duty of responsibility". The "duty of responsibility" came into force to replace the much-criticised so-called "presumption of guilt" for UK senior managers on May 10, 2016. The new duty applies to persons performing senior management functions at UK banks, building societies, credit unions, investment firms designated by the Prudential Regulation Authority and incoming branches of overseas firms. Under this duty, the FCA and the PRA can take enforcement action against Senior Managers if they are responsible for the management of any activities in their firm in relation to which their firm contravenes a regulatory requirement and they do not take such steps as a person in their position could reasonably be expected to take to avoid the contravention occurring or continuing. The burden of proof lies with the regulators to prove a contravention. The Guidance applied from May 3, 2017.
View the Policy Statement.
UK Banking Standards Board Publishes Fitness and Propriety Assessment Principles
The Banking Standards Board has published the Statement of Good Practice 1 on the Certification Regime: fitness and propriety assessment principles and Supporting Guidance for the Statement of Good Practice. The BSB was launched in April 2015 to help raise standards of behavior and competence in the banking sector. The Certification Regime, part of the regulatory reforms introduced in the UK to strengthen individual accountability, requires firms to certify that all individuals in roles which pose a risk of significant harm are "fit and proper". The first certification process was due to be completed by March 7, 2017 and thereafter firms must conduct assessments on an ongoing basis.
US Office of the Comptroller of the Currency Issues Revised Comptroller’s Licensing Manual Booklet
The OCC issued a revised version of the “Changes in Directors and Senior Executive Officers” booklet of the Comptroller’s Licensing Manual. This revised booklet replaces the prior version which was issued in October 2009, and incorporates updated regulations that became effective July 1, 2015, addressing changes in directors and senior executive officers of national banks, federal savings associations, and federal branches of non-US banks. Specifically, the revised booklet explains when prior notice for changes in directors and senior executive officers is required, provides institutions with information regarding the contents of complete notices and addresses the 90-day review period.
View the updated booklet.
European Banking Authority Publishes Final Draft Technical Standards on Information Sharing Between National Regulators for Passporting of Payment Services
The European Banking Authority published final draft Regulatory Technical Standards on the cooperation and exchange of information between national regulators where an authorized payment institution would like to provide payment services in a Member State other than its home Member State (so-called passporting) under the Payment Services Directive (also known as PSD2). The Directive aims to make payments between Member States as secure, easy and efficient as those made within a Member State. PSD2 focuses on electronic payments and payment services within the EU, regulating new types of payment services and payment services providers, which are currently unregulated, and stimulating competition in the electronic payments market. The RTS aim to ensure that information about those entities that carry out business in EU Member States is exchanged between national regulators in a consistent way, that there is clarity for payment institutions about their regulatory requirements and specifies the information that is to be shared between national regulators. The EBA consulted on draft RTS in late 2015 and, having taken feedback into account, has made certain amendments to the final draft RTS, including removing some of the information requirements on payment institutions relating to governance arrangements and internal control mechanisms, outsourcing and the agent structural organization. In addition, the EBA has now provided separate templates for when a payment institution or e-money institution is using an agent or when a distributor is used.
European Central Bank Publishes Draft Guidance on Fit and Proper Assessment
The European Central Bank published for consultation draft Guidance on the fit and proper assessment of members of management bodies of significant banks. The ECB is responsible for direct prudential supervision of certain significant banks based in the Eurozone as part of the Single Supervisory Mechanism. The purpose of the draft Guidance is to outline how the ECB will evaluate the qualifications, skills and proper standing of a candidate for becoming a member of a management body. The draft Guidance builds on the current draft guidance under the Capital Requirements Directive and the revised Markets in Financial Instruments Directive published by the European Securities and Markets Authority and the European Banking Authority on October 28, 2016. The assessment criteria for the fitness and proprietary of members of the management body are outlined in the draft Guidance. The criteria include experience, reputation, conflicts of interest and independence of mind, time commitment and collective suitability. The draft Guidance provides information on the purpose, scope and type of interviews conducted by the ECB of appointees. The draft Guidance highlights how a decision is taken by the ECB after every fit and proper assessment and the various types of decisions that may be taken. The draft Guidance also notes that under the SSM Regulation, the ECB has the power to remove, at any time, members from the management body of a significant supervised entity who do not fulfill the fit and proper requirements, which is provided for in the SSM Regulation. The ECB is seeking feedback on its draft Guidance by January 20, 2017.
View the draft Guidance.
European Banking Authority Proposes Guidelines on Internal Governance
The European Banking Authority launched a consultation on draft revised Guidelines on internal governance for credit institutions and investment firms. The EU Capital Requirements Directive imposes governance requirements on banks and investment firms which include, amongst other things, requirements to have robust governance arrangements, to establish a risk committee and nomination committee and to have adequate risk management processes and internal controls. CRD requires the EBA to develop Guidelines on internal governance. The proposed new Guidelines set out the internal governance arrangements, processes and mechanisms that firms must implement to ensure effective management of the firm. The Guidelines will apply to a firm's governance arrangements, including their organizational structure and processes to identify, manage, monitor and report risks that they may be exposed to, taking into account the three lines of defense model. The EBA's current Guidelines on internal governance, published on September 27, 2011, will be repealed when the new Guidelines enter into force. Responses to the consultation are due by January 28, 2017.
View the consultation paper and proposed revised Guidelines.
View the current Guidelines.
EU Consultation on Assessing the Suitability of Management
The European Banking Authority and the European Securities and Markets Authority launched a joint consultation on proposed Guidelines on the Assessment of the Suitability of the Members of Management Body and Key Function Holders. The revised Markets in Financial Instruments Directive and the Capital Requirements Directive require firms to assess the suitability of members of their management body. Firms subject to CRD must all assess the suitability of all key function holders that have a significant influence over the direction of the firm. The proposed Guidelines provide criteria for assessing the individual and collective knowledge, skills, experience, reputation, honesty, integrity and independence of members of the management body. The proposed Guidelines also include a framework for assessing whether individual members of management commit sufficient time to performing their duties, set out how diversity should be taken into account in the selection process for members of the management body and provide for appropriate financial and human resources to be allocated to induction and training.
View the consultation paper.
US Securities and Exchange Commission Proposes Amendments to Require Use of Universal Proxy Cards
The US Securities and Exchange Commission voted to propose amendments to the proxy rules to require parties in a contested election to use universal proxy cards that would include the names of all board of director nominees. The proposal gives shareholders the ability to vote by proxy for their preferred combination of board candidates, similar to voting in person.
The proposed rules would require proxy contestants to provide shareholders with a proxy card that includes the names of both management and dissident director nominees. The rules would apply to all non-exempt solicitations for contested elections other than those involving registered investment companies and business development companies. In addition, the proposed rules would require management and dissidents to provide each other with notice of the names of their nominees, establish a filing deadline and a minimum solicitation requirement for dissidents, and prescribe presentation and formatting requirements for universal proxy cards.
To further facilitate shareholder voting in director elections, the SEC also voted to propose amendments to the proxy rules to ensure that proxy cards specify the applicable shareholder voting options in all director elections and require that proxy statements disclose the effect of a shareholder’s election to withhold its vote.
Comments should be received on or before January 9, 2017.
View proposed rule.
Bank of England Proposes Code of Practice for Recognized Payment System Operators
The Bank of England published a consultation paper proposing the introduction of a draft Code of Practice and Supervisory Statement on governance in recognized payment system operators. The final Code and the Supervisory Statement will contain the minimum governance requirements and expectations for recognized payment system operators to meet. Recognized payment systems include Bacs, CREST, CHAPS, LINK and Faster Payment Services. The Principles for financial market infrastructures, developed by the Committee on Payment and Settlement Systems and the International Organization of Securities Commissions, form the basis of the draft Code although the Bank has also taken into account other sources such as the UK Corporate Governance Code. Amongst other things, the draft Code would require a recognized payment system operator to be a systemic risk manager (by promoting the safety and efficiency of the payment system and supporting the stability of the financial system), review its performance annually and document its governance policies and procedures. It would also set out the requirements for composition of the board and expectations on governance arrangements. It is not intended that the Code would apply to a recognized payment system that is operated by a recognized clearing house or central securities depository because those entities are already subject to similar requirements under the European Market Infrastructure Regulation or the Central Securities Depositories Regulation. The Bank of England is proposing that the Code be implemented 12 months after publication of the final version. The consultation closes on December 2, 2016.
View the consultation paper.
UK Regulators Move to Amend UK's Senior Manager & Certification Regime
The Prudential Regulation Authority and the Financial Conduct Authority launched a consultation proposing amendments to the Senior Manager & Certification Regime. Most of the changes result from the legislative changes made in the Bank of England and Financial Services Act 2016. However, the regulators are also proposing some other changes which they consider appropriate having had the opportunity to assess the SM&CR in practice.
UK Regulators Propose Extending Some of Their Whistleblowing Requirements to UK Branches of Overseas Banks
The Prudential Regulation Authority and the Financial Conduct Authority launched separate consultations on proposals to extend some of their whistleblowing requirements to UK branches of non-EEA banks. The proposals do not apply to UK branches of EEA banks. The regulators are proposing that non-EEA banks should be required to inform their employees about the regulators' whistleblowing services. Moreover, any non-EEA banking group that has both a UK subsidiary and a UK branch should inform branch staff about the subsidiary's whistleblowing arrangements. The PRA is also proposing that all insurers should inform employees about whistleblowing procedures. Since September 7, 2016, UK banks, building societies and credit unions with assets of £250 million or greater, PRA-designated investment firms, insurance and reinsurance firms within the scope of Solvency II or regulated by the Society of Lloyd's, as well as Lloyd's managing agents, have been required to implement internal whistleblowing procedures.They must also inform employees of the internal procedures and the whistleblowing services provided by the PRA and FCA and to ensure that employment contracts and settlement agreements do not deter employees from whistleblowing. Responses to the consultation are requested by January 9, 2017. The final rules are expected to apply from September 2017.
View the PRA's consultation paper.
View the FCA's consultation paper.
UK Regulators Revise Rules on Regulatory References
The Prudential Regulation Authority and the Financial Conduct Authority published revised rules on regulatory references for banking and insurance firms subject to the Senior Manager and Certification Regime and the Senior Insurance Manager Regime, respectively. Regulatory references are employment references passed between firms when an individual moves roles.
UK Financial Conduct Authority Discusses the Application of the Senior Managers Regime to a Firm's Legal Function
The Financial Conduct Authority published a discussion paper about how and why the legal function currently falls within the Senior Manager & Certification Regimes and whether it should continue to do so. In the lead up to implementation of the SM&CR in March 2016, the FCA became aware of significant uncertainty amongst firms as to whether an individual responsible for the management of a firm's legal function would require approval as a Senior Manager. Where heads of legal are responsible for compliance, there is a clear need to register, but the position is less clear for heads of legal who do not hold this additional function.
Financial Stability Board Reports on Progress on its Workplan to Reduce Misconduct Risk
The Financial Stability Board published a second progress report on its workplan to reduce misconduct risk. The workplan was first agreed in May 2015 and the FSB published its first progress report in November 2015. The workplan involves: (i) reviewing the effectiveness of reforms to compensation tools in reducing the risk of misconduct; (ii) examining whether the global standards of conduct in the fixed income, commodities and currency (FICC) markets need to be improved; and (iii) reforming the major financial benchmarks. The FSB's second progress report sets out the progress made to date as well as the expected dates for finalization of some of the work. By the end of 2016, the International Organization of Securities Commissions will publish final guidance for benchmark administrators on the content of the statements of compliance that administrators will be conducting a follow-up review of WM/Reuters 4 pm London Closing Spot Rate. The report also noted current reforms to the key IBOR benchmarks with a final report to be released in the course of 2017. Other items that are in the pipeline include publishing recommendations on the application of regulatory compensation tools to reduce misconduct risk by the end of 2017 and a wide-ranging FX Global Code for the wholesale foreign exchange market is expected to be finalized by May 2017.
View the progress report.
Report on Implementation of Global Corporate Governance Principles
The Organization for Economic Co-operation and Development published a progress report on the implementation of the G20/OECD Principles of Corporate Governance. The Principles were endorsed by G20 Leaders at their summit in Antalya on November 15-16, 2015 and are one of the Key Standards for Sound Financial Systems adopted by the Financial Stability Board. The progress report provides an update on the main developments that have helped jurisdictions to implement the Principles, including translations of the Principles into languages other than the official languages of the OECD. It also discusses the review and update of the methodology used by the OECD to assess the implementation of the Principles, as well as containing information on the FSB peer review of the implementation of the relevant Principles. The review will assess how FSB member jurisdictions have implemented the Principles for publicly listed financial institutions, such as banks, insurers, asset managers and financial holding companies. The final version of the Methodology is expected to be adopted in November 2016. The OECD intends to continue with its thematic peer reviews and the next peer review is expected to launch in the first half of 2017.
View the progress report.
UK Prudential Regulator Reminds CRR Firms about Management Body Diversity
The UK Prudential Regulation Authority published an open letter to all firms subject to the Capital Requirements Regulation reminding firms of the requirement in the PRA Rulebook to have in place a policy promoting diversity on the management body. The letter follows a report by the European Banking Authority on Benchmarking Diversity Practices published on July 8, 2016. The PRA cited the report which highlighted that, of UK firms surveyed, only 15% had a policy to promote diversity on their management body. The PRA is also interested in how firms have promoted diversity among Senior Managers.
View the letter.
View the General Organisational Requirements.
View the EBA Report.
Financial Stability Board Launches Thematic Peer Review on Corporate Governance
The Financial Stability Board launched its thematic peer review regarding the implementation of the G20/Organisation for Economic Co-Operation and Development (OECD) Principles of Corporate Governance. These Principles have been designated as one of the FSB’s key standards for sound financial systems. The Principles cover governance frameworks, disclosure and transparency, rights and equitable treatment of shareholders, key ownership functions and responsibilities. The objective of the peer review, as outlined in the terms of reference, is to understand and assess how FSB member jurisdictions have applied the principles to publicly listed regulated financial institutions (banks, insurers, asset managers and financial holding companies). The FSB is seeking feedback on, for example, the design of corporate governance frameworks and whether they promote transparent and fair markets, the protection of shareholders rights and how corporate governance structures can facilitate equitable treatment for all shareholders. The review is limited to those Principles which apply to listed regulated financial institutions, but it is hoped that it may allow for a more in-depth analysis of particular topics which are relevant for the FSB's broader remit.
The feedback is due by September 9, 2016 with a final report expected to be published in early 2017.
View the FSB terms of reference.
View the G20/OECD Principles of Corporate Governance.
US Federal Banking FAQ for Assessing Diversity Policies and Practices of Regulated Institutions
The US Federal Reserve Board, the FDIC and the OCC issued frequently asked questions (FAQs) regarding the process for how financial institutions they regulate may begin to submit self-assessments of their diversity policies and practices starting with year-end 2015. Section 342 of the Dodd-Frank Wall Street Reform and Consumer Protection Act requires the federal financial regulatory agencies to develop standards for assessing the diversity policies and practices of its regulated institutions, which became effective on June 10, 2015. The standards provide a framework for regulated institutions to assess and establish or strengthen their diversity policies and practices. Financial institutions are strongly encouraged to disclose on their websites their diversity policies and practices, as well as information related to their self-assessments, to maximize transparency, and to provide their policies, practices and self-assessment information to their primary federal financial regulator.
UK Legislation Implements Provisions of The Bank of England and Financial Services Act 2016
The Bank of England and Financial Services Act 2016 (Commencement No. 3) Regulations 2016 were made. The Regulations bring a majority of the provisions in The Bank of England and Financial Services Act 2016 into force. Such provisions cover topics such as financial stability strategy, Financial Policy Committee: status and membership, Monetary Policy Committee: membership and procedure, audit, activities indemnified by Treasury, appointment of Financial Conduct Authority chief executive, Treasury recommendations to the Financial Conduct Authority, administration of senior managers regime, rules of conduct, decisions causing a financial institution to fail: meaning of insolvency, enforceability of agreements relating to credit, illegal money lending and banks authorized to issue banknotes in Scotland and Northern Ireland.
The provisions will enter into force on July 6, 2016.
View the Regulations.
UK Senior Manager Misconduct Provisions Come Into Force
Two pieces of secondary legislation brought the revised provisions published on May 5th in the Bank of England and Financial Services Act 2016 on senior manager misconduct into force. The revised provisions replace the presumption of responsibility for a senior manager when a breach of regulatory provisions occurs in the area that he is responsible for (originally brought in by the Financial Services (Banking Reform) Act 2013), with a duty of responsibility. For a senior manager to be found guilty of misconduct by one of the UK regulators, the Prudential Regulation Authority and/or Financial Conduct Authority will need to prove that a senior manager did not take reasonable steps to prevent the contravention by his firm from occurring or continuing.
View the Order.
View the Regulations.
UK Senior Manager and Certification Regime Amendments and Extension Final
The Bank of England and Financial Services Act 2016 was passed by the UK Parliament. The Act includes amendments to the Senior Manager and Certification Regime and extends the SM&CR to all UK authorized firms. The amendments include removing the presumption of responsibility for a senior manager when a breach of regulatory provisions occurs in the area that he is responsible for, replacing it with a duty of responsibility. In addition, the UK regulators are granted specific powers to take enforcement action against all non-executive directors of firms for their misconduct. The extension of the SM&CR follows from the recommendations of the Fair and Effective Markets Review, published in June 2015, that the regime should be extended to wholesale participants in the fixed income, currency and commodity markets.
Certain provisions of the Act came into effect immediately. The provisions on senior management will come into effect once HM Treasury adopts regulations providing for the effective date. It is not yet known when the extension to all UK authorized firms will occur but the UK regulators have mentioned 2018 in the past.
View the Act.
View HM Treasury’s press release.
View the Bank of England’s press release.
You might like to view our client note.
US Securities and Exchange Commission Chair Mary Jo White Discusses Technology Developments and Governance Challenges in Financial Markets
US Securities and Exchange Commission Chair Mary Jo White discussed the importance of strong governance and investor protection in the wake of developments and innovation in technology and financial markets. Specifically, Chair White discussed the importance of pre-IPO companies making accurate disclosures, and in particular the implications and potential consequences of the increase in so-called "unicorns" which are private start-up firms with valuations that exceed $1 billion. White also remarked on the need to protect investors that are investing under new SEC rules for capital raising under the JOBS Act -Regulation D, Regulation A+ and Regulation Crowdfunding - all of which are designed to allow smaller companies to access the capital markets. White noted that implicit in improving investor protection are strong financial controls and corporate governance, topics which are particularly important for private pre-IPO companies particularly as they go public and grow, often exponentially. Tools such as ensuring relevant expertise on boards and implementing investor protections while pre-IPO companies are private can help mitigate against the risks faced by rapidly growing start-ups. Finally, White noted that the SEC is closely monitoring developments and related investor protection issues in digital finance or fintech, namely blockchain technology, automated investment advice (robo-advisors) and online marketplace lending platforms.
View Chair White’s speech.
UK Regulator Publishes Policy Statement and Supervisory Statement on Board Responsibilities
The Prudential Regulation Authority published a Policy Statement and Supervisory Statement on board responsibilities. The Policy is relevant to all PRA-regulated firms - banks, insurers, designated investment firms, building societies, friendly societies and credit unions. The Supervisory Statement provides PRA guidance on aspects of corporate governance to which the PRA attaches particular importance and to which the PRA may devote particular attention in the course of its supervision. The list, which is not definitive, includes firm strategy, culture, risk appetite and management, board composition, roles of executive and non-executive directors, board time and resources, management information and transparency, succession planning, remuneration, subsidiary boards and board sub-committees. The Supervisory Statement notes that specific accountabilities of individual directors established by the Senior Managers Regime are additional and complementary to the collective responsibility shared by directors as members of the board.
View the policy statement.
View the supervisory statement.
UK Regulators Remove Certain Rules under Senior Manager and Certification Regimes
The Prudential Regulation Authority and the Financial Conduct Authority published final rules removing certain requirements under the Senior Manager and Certification Regimes. The regulators consulted earlier this year on the proposed amendments which are necessary as a result of the proposed changes to the regime that have been proposed by the UK Government, including extending the regime to all financial services firms, removing the obligation on a firm to notify the PRA or FCA when it knows or suspects that a senior manager or certified person has failed to comply with the conduct rules and replacing the presumption of responsibility with a duty of responsibility. It remains to be seen whether Parliament will approve the equivalent changes that have been proposed by the Government to legislation. An amending Order, published in December 2015, stops the above-mentioned notification requirement and the presumption of responsibility from coming into force on March 7, 2016 – the date when the remainder of the new Regime will come into effect. The regulators' rules and forms have been amended to reflect this position. The PRA has also made changes to the definition of 'significant risk taker' which sets the parameters of its Certification Regime. The amendment aims to align the definition of SRT with a 'material risk taker' under the Remuneration rules.
View the FCA Policy Statement and final rules.
View the PRA Policy Statement and final rules.
UK Regulators Joint Policy Statement on Regulatory References, Implementation of Senior Manager and Certification Regimes and Senior Insurance Managers Regime
The Prudential Regulation Authority and Financial Conduct Authority jointly published a Policy Statement on the implementation of the Senior Manager and Certification Regimes, Senior Insurance Managers Regime and the requirements of the PRA on regulatory references. The Policy Statement, amongst other things, sets out a first set of PRA rules on the provision of regulatory references by firms under the SM&CR and SIMR, i.e., employment references passed between firms when an individual moves roles. These PRA rules are set out in Appendix 1 of the Policy Statement and will apply from March 7, 2016. The rules are largely a continuation of the existing requirements under the Approved Persons Regime and should be read and applied together with the FCA's equivalent requirements. The FCA's Policy Statement was published on February 4, 2016 and sets out the feedback received on the PRA and FCA's joint consultation on regulatory references. A second set of rules are expected to be published at a later date and will cover the areas on which feedback received by the PRA is still under consideration.
View the PRA and FCA's Policy Statement.
View the FCA's Policy Statement.
UK Regulator Extends the Senior Manager and Certification Regime
The Financial Conduct Authority published a Policy Statement and final rules on the application of the Senior Manager and Certification Regimes to wholesale market activities, such as algorithmic and high-frequency trading. The SM&CR enters into force on March 7, 2016. The rules apply to banks, building societies, and investment firms designated by the Prudential Regulation Authority. The new rules extend the Certification regime to individuals who carry out two new significant harm functions: (i) the new "client dealing" function, which includes advising on investments other than non-investment insurance contracts and any associated dealing and arranging, acting as an investment manager or acting as a bidder's representative (this new function is subject to the FCA's new definition of "client" which aims to capture all clients including traditional retail clients); and (ii) "algorithmic trading". Under transitional rules, the Certification regime requires firms to identify the staff members that fall into the two new functions and train them on the new conduct rules by September 7, 2016. The commencement date for the requirement for firms to certify all staff that carry out significant harm functions remains March 7, 2017.
UK Regulators to Investigate Former HBOS Senior Managers
The Prudential Regulation Authority and the Financial Conduct Authority announced that they would be conducting an investigation into certain former senior managers of HBOS plc. This is the entity which resulted from merger of the Halifax Building Society and Bank of Scotland, which following financial failings was placed into state ownership in 2008. The decision follows the recommendations made by Andrew Green Q.C. in his final Report into the Financial Services Authority's enforcement actions following the failure of HBOS, in particular that the regulators should conduct investigations to determine whether any prohibition proceedings should be brought against the relevant individuals.
View the PRA press release.
View the report of Andrew Green Q.C.